i think your taking an unfair advantage of Walmart return policy. To me it kind of has the same feel as someone buying a toy and replacing it with another unwanted toy and returning it for credit. I know its not the same thing but that's sort of how I see it. Of course this is what I think if the two stores and not connected in anyway.
Never, ever put me in the same boat as a toy swapper. Those guys are flat out scum. The product that I returned as the exact same as what was on the floor, never opened. Xbox seal still intact. The value of what I returned was the same as compensated for. Toy swapper swap out product with something that is not original and someone will be cheated when they purchase it. In my case, if someone buys this game, they get the game, never opened.
Look at this way. You have a child and buy them a Wolverine figure from Zellers for Christmas. Grandma buys the exact same Wolverine for you child from Walmart. You have not given you child Wolverine yet and don't want to ask Grandma for a receipt, so you use your receipt from Zellers and return Wolverine. Same figure, purchased from a different store. Better yet, Grandam lives in the US and bought Wolverine from Target and you return your to Walmart. Different stores, same result. Happens all the time.
The product is the same.
Toy swappers on the other hand are lying to the cashier when they return it. I was honest and asked directly if I knew where it came from I would have said "Old Navy, but they don't have Fable 3 there, and that's what I'm looking for."
More details on my story:
There was a sticker covering the UPC on the back. The girl had to remove the sticker in order to scan the correct code. I smiled and said "I'm just looking for store credit". Her response was "I have to see if it's in the system". I told her it would be as I visually checked there store stock before I came to her. She checked the inventory and saw that they do carry it. It is the only way she could assign a value to my return.
She said "We carry it." then she had to page the CSM (Customer Service Manager) to approve the return as it was over $50.00. So she came by, looked at it and punched in her code to approve the transaction.
I should also point out that if they said no I was willing to say "No harm in asking" and take it to Best buy across the street as I had already called them and they said they would take it as a used game (even though it was still wrapped) and give me $25.00 credit. So I had a plan B.
It's unused, it will sell out, and I invested an addition sum of money on top of the purchase.
I feel no guilt and I'm the kind of guy who can't lye to save his life.
